Welcome to Matthew’s 1600
Matthew’s 1600 in Catonsville, MD offers a diverse American menu with an emphasis on seafood and hearty dishes like prime rib. The restaurant has a cozy atmosphere and attentive service. Customers rave about their rockfish, crab dishes, and giant chocolate chip cookie dessert. The management is praised for their excellent customer service and willingness to make things right when mistakes occur. With a historic building dating back to the 1800s, Matthew’s 1600 exudes charm and offers a memorable dining experience for guests.
-
1600 Frederick Rd Catonsville, MD 21228 Hotline: (410) 788-2500
Welcome to Matthew’s 1600, a beloved American restaurant located at 1600 Frederick Rd in Catonsville, MD. This restaurant offers a wide range of amenities including reservations, takeout, delivery, vegetarian options, wheelchair accessibility, and more. With a full bar, happy hour specials, and a cozy atmosphere, Matthew’s 1600 is the perfect spot for lunch, dinner, and everything in between.
Customers rave about the delicious food and exceptional service at Matthew’s 1600. From the mouthwatering rockfish to the indulgent chocolate chip cookie dessert, every dish is sure to delight your taste buds. Whether you’re craving a classic prime rib or want to try something new like the Pasta Annapolis or the Monte Cristo, Matthew’s 1600 has something for everyone.
With rave reviews from loyal customers who appreciate the attentive staff and cozy atmosphere, Matthew’s 1600 is a must-visit for anyone in the Catonsville area. Don’t miss out on this gem of a restaurant that offers Baltimore staples with a twist. Visit Matthew’s 1600 today and experience the magic for yourself.
Yesterday I celebrated a very special birthday and topped off the day with dinner at Matthews 1600 in Catonsville. I have enjoyed lunches there but never dinner. I chose it because I craved prime rib and a baked potato and COULD NOT FIND IT on local menus. I got sidetracked, though, because rockfish was on the menu. YUM! That beat prime rib. However, it came with a side of rice, corn, and crab with Old Bay, a spice my tummy can no longer handle. I ordered the potato to substitute, but in addition they made the rice dish with no Old Bay just for me. OMG, was it DELICIOUS!! (I think it would make a nice entree by itself if you beef up the crab a little.). So then it was dessert time and my birthday, so how could I resist? They have a dessert consisting of two of the biggest chocolate chip cookies in memory served as a sandwich with ice cream. My husband and I split it. Yum! We could barely walk out! This was one of the best meals out I have had in a VERY long time!
I have been to this restaurant a few time and had good experiences overall I ordered the surf and turf on10/20/2024 and when I got home the crab cake wasnt there. I called the restaurant to advise and also let them know of the price on the website was the same as I was charged. I went back to the restaurant, and they did advise the site was not updated with pricing. I was a bit disappointed, however management was so great and apologetic and explain the situation. They said they could quickly make me 2 crab cakes and provides a discount. In the end I was pleased more so with the customer service, them taking accountability and offer a win win solution. I will go back again, and the food was great. normjmc@yahoo.com
Great food, cozy atmosphere, and good service. Manager who cares. I had a problem with my entree. The Manger was right there and made everything perfect. Their quiche is silky and flavorful. The Pasta Annapolis is SO good! Their Espresso Martini was excellent. Neighborhood Gem!
I looked at the menu and quickly chose a monte cristo to eat. I was intrigued by the "crush bar" on the cocktails menu. My first time to Maryland (that I remember in any case) do I decided I needed to try a flight of crushes. Orange, Creamsicle, Pineapple, and Strawberry Lemon. And you will have a hard time convincing me they even have alcohol..just yummy juice! Needless to say, my lunch was fantastic. And I read about the history of the location on the menu, and this place wins on all counts!! The service was great, and with a building from the 180's, how could we get better atmosphere? A great stop in our road trip!
A great and versatile eatery. We love coming here and they never disappoint. The menu changes frequently.
Wow! Matthew's is an example of how the smallest towns can produce the best restaurants. The food is terrific (although the pancakes I ordered once were very sweet), the service is fast, and the young wait staff is surprisingly very professional. The hostesses are efficient and warm, and the waiters are friendly. My food has never come out wrong at Matthews- even when I remove things from certain dishes. Overall a fantastic restaurant that you shouldn't miss in Catonsville!
I hadn't been here in years but I did remember they had great service, and they didn't disappoint me this time as well. We were able to sit in a private dining room and the decor was very classy and comfortable. The waitress made some recommendations that we followed and I'm glad we did. The food was good and very much Baltimore staples. I will definitely be back again soon.
Matthew's has been around for a long time , it is a great meeting place , and dining . So close to me so we frequent it a lot . The food is usually good , great selection . Prices somewhat high , service good . I love their crab dip really good , as usual my husband got oysters which he loves Then onto the crab cake platter.He loves their crab cakes I got the Avalon a sandwich of beef strips, onions and cheese , delicious. My husband had beer and I had ice cold water A good place to dine and relax , and eat good food